Search visibility scorecard — publishing search advice since 2012 Direct line 1-323-505-6622

Learn› Selling My Product Online› Ebay vs Amazon Selling

Another Get Found Fact

Ebay vs Amazon Selling

The real Pros and Cons of both third-party marketplaces — fees, payment timing, conversion, customer interaction and competition — written for entrepreneurs deciding where to list first. This is the longest guide in our library.

Reviewed and Updated October 2026. This guide was published on 30 May 2017 and the comparison frame still holds. Six groups of specific claims in it — fee percentages, free-listing allowances, payment hold periods, the eBay–PayPal relationship, guarantee terms and competition levels — are set by the marketplaces and change whenever they like, so each passage carries a dated yellow note where it sits. David’s text is as he wrote it. The notes are the update.

Hey there everybody it’s David Scarpitta. Welcome back to another Get Found Fact. We are going to answer the question alot of people have which is Ebay vs Amazon Selling.

Let’s start with the details of both Both Ebay and Amazon. Here’s the Pros on Both the Ebay vs Amazon Selling Space.

Ebay Pros

PRO 01Lower Overall Fees to Start

Much of the time, Ebay will give you many free listings just to start. You get to sample test where you are going to be in your ebay business. We’re talking as many as 500 free listings (from what I have seen recently), to be able to kickstart your online business. And future listings are just some pocket change in the event you start to scale or you go through all of your free listings already.

TIME-SENSITIVE · CLAIM GROUP 1 · REVIEWED AND UPDATED OCTOBER 2026 “as many as 500 free listings (from what I have seen recently)” was what David was seeing in May 2017, and he said so in the sentence. Marketplace listing allowances are changed by the platform whenever it likes. Treat the number as a 2017 observation, not as today’s offer, and check the allowance on eBay before you plan around it.

PRO 02Lower Closing Sales Fees

Finalizing a sale, you will literally take home more raw funds than the big A. Depending on your item or items you are selling, this is an important structure to take into consideration for overall profitability.

TIME-SENSITIVE · CLAIM GROUP 2 · REVIEWED AND UPDATED OCTOBER 2026 Which marketplace leaves you more per sale is a fee-schedule comparison, and both schedules have been rewritten more than once since 2017. Price out your own category on both platforms’ current fee pages before choosing.

PRO 03Faster Payment Methods

Almost instant payment via Paypal (Granted Your Account is Not Under Risk Control). Instant cash for your transaction so that you have cash flow for shipping and restocking products. Ebay owns Paypal and has a direct working relationship, so you’l get paid fairly fast as compared to other platforms where you may have to wait up to 15 business days. Which obviously can hurt cash flow in some businesses.

TIME-SENSITIVE · CLAIM GROUPS 4 + 5 · REVIEWED AND UPDATED OCTOBER 2026 · HIGHEST RISK ON THE PAGE This paragraph makes two claims that are structural, not incidental: “Ebay owns Paypal” and “Almost instant payment via Paypal”. Corporate ownership and the payment rail a marketplace puts its sellers on are exactly the kind of fact that moves. eBay and PayPal have been separate companies since 2015, and eBay has since moved its sellers onto its own managed payments, so the payout speed described here is the 2017 picture. The cash-flow argument of this article rests on it: check eBay’s current payout terms before you build a plan on this paragraph.

PRO 04Ebay Offers More Control Over Your Product Listings

You make independent listings for all of your products. You have a substantial amount of control for your products that you are selling. This also enables you to “SEO Your Ebay Listing”, however we will talk more about this in another article.

PRO 05Ebay Offers More (And Encourages) More Customer Interactions

This can be a double edged sword and can be a positive or a negative. From a positive side, since Ebay has “several type of product listings”. For example “Auction Listing”, “Buy it Now”, and even a “Best Offer” type of product listing. Now depending on what type of product you have, as well as marketplace and the liquidity you need for the product.

“Basically it comes down to whether or not you want interaction.” DAVID SCARPITTA · 30 MAY 2017

This interaction can enhance the ability to close the sale on larger ticket items, or things that “aren’t priced to move”. This instills the trust factor for a larger priced item.

However interaction can move in the opposite direction as well, where this opens communication for “ignored content” because the potential customer did not receive the description of the product well, or just ignored it completely, and winds up asking multiple mundane questions wasting lots of time for you and not resulting in the sale.

PRO 06Competition is Sporadic

Many of the other businesses potentially selling the same product are sporadic. These potential competitors may not be listed on the same search page and they are not usually grouped together. Therefore their overall listing may not be seen, and therefore gives you a leg up in potentially crowded space. Especially given the fact you have more control over the product listing and it’s independent customizations.

Pros of Selling on Amazon

PRO 01Conversion on Amazon is Higher

One of the core reasons that Amazon conversion rate is higher is because of it’s traffic. It’s a known fact that if you have much more traffic, there is a chance for more web traffic converting to sales. Overall Amazon has some of the highest conversion rates on the internet and in e-commerce. We talk more about this in other lessons regarding increasing website conversion.

TIME-SENSITIVE · CLAIM GROUP 6 · REVIEWED AND UPDATED OCTOBER 2026 The relative conversion rates of the two marketplaces are stated here without a source, as a general observation. No figure is given, and we are not going to add one — we do not publish numbers we have not measured. Read it as David’s 2017 read of the two platforms.

PRO 02The A to Z Guarantee Is Trusted

The A to Z guarantee gives the purchaser or customer, the unfettered ability to complain about absolutely anything. The A to Z guarantee instills a “buyer trust” like no other. From a buyer’s perspective, the trust factor stomps out most other retailers. With this in mind, this order performance guarantee takes the large traffic and brand of Amazon and further increases the conversion of the potential product being sold.

PRO 03Better Organization of Products on The Amazon Site

Amazon has an insanely large selection of products from both themselves, and 3rd party sellers. With such a large breadth of products and services, Amazon takes a strong organizational approach of presenting similar products in a less confusing fashion. They take a handful of listings of similar products, and present almost every seller in a “product and seller comparison page” where everything is neatly kept into focus to find the most competitive price for the same product literally browseable in seconds. Amazon forces continued organization of all sellers on the marketplace.

PRO 04Amazon Makes Transactions and Purchasing Extremely Easy

To enhance the continued growth of Amazon sales, and enhance their conversion the Amazon checkout process for both buying and selling. From a seller’s perspective, there is FBA, product Questions & Answers, and product reviews and details that surpass most independent retail ecommerce websites.

When it comes to the “buyer experience”, Amazon makes it so painless to both purchase, re-order, and track everything in one-click via both directly through the website, and then even the super easy mobile app for both iOS and Android.

Now for every Pro, there is obviously a Con. So let’s take a look at some of the cons. Continuing on with, Ebay vs Amazon Selling Pros and Cons.

Cons of Selling on Ebay

CON 01Ebay has lower overall conversion

Ebay visitors do alot of tire-kicking, browsing and question asking. The perception of Ebay is that it’s the “garage sale of the internet”. Great for impulse items that are hard to find, and very rare items to the “highest bidder”. People understand that the “A to Z Protection plan” isn’t in place for Ebay, and the trust factor pushes down the conversion.

“The perception of Ebay is that it’s the ‘garage sale of the internet’.”DAVID SCARPITTA · 30 MAY 2017
TIME-SENSITIVE · CLAIM GROUP 6 · REVIEWED AND UPDATED OCTOBER 2026 “the ‘A to Z Protection plan’ isn’t in place for Ebay” is a claim about a competitor’s buyer-protection policy in 2017. Marketplace protection programmes get renamed and rewritten. Check both platforms’ current buyer-protection terms rather than relying on this line.

CON 02Ebay Listings Expire, and You Have to Relist

No matter the type of product you are listing, you have to “relist” the item from time to time. Even if you decide to have a “long term listing”, much of the time there will always be some manual function to have “renew” your Ebay listing no matter the type of Auction, Buy it Now or “Best Offer”, you’ll be relisting eventually. We talk about a way to automate relisting Ebay listings in other posts.

CON 03Ebay Equals Potentially More Customer Interaction Required

As i mentioned earlier, customer interaction on Ebay can actually be something that helps you garner a better profit for your products, however this “easy to ask questions directly” to the seller is sometimes a total time waster. Since many potential Ebay customers are always looking for an extreme deal, sometimes they may waste alot of time by not reading the listing where you answer all the product questions, or consistently ask for more pictures, details, and even a price negotiation with no real intention of closing the deal or making the purchase.

CON 04Getting Paid on Ebay is Subject to Having to Use Paypal

Being able to get paid fairly instantly really does help when it comes to cash flow for your business substantially, however you’re locked to using Paypal. If you don’t like Paypal, or you’ve had “Paypal Issues or Paypal Disputes”, you are going to be held back sometimes indefinitely and really fighting to try to get your money. Again, every platform unless you are on your own ecommerce site, then you are at the will of the 3rd party network payment processing protocols.

TIME-SENSITIVE · CLAIM GROUP 5 · REVIEWED AND UPDATED OCTOBER 2026 “you’re locked to using Paypal” is the same payment-rail claim as Pro 03, stated as a constraint. Whether a seller is still locked to one processor on this marketplace has not been re-checked. The last sentence — that on anyone else’s platform you are at the will of their payment protocols — is the durable point, and it is the reason we push clients toward owning their own ecommerce site.

Cons when Selling on Amazon

CON 01Amazon Seller Fees Can Be Extremely High At Times

Amazon is a conversion and selling powerhouse. They know this, and are raking in millions of dollars in fees to sell on their platform. From extended FBA fees, to shipping fees and product categorization final sale fees on average from 15-18% of the total purchase price of your item. This can leave you with some real scraps and may ultimately affect your operations and bottom line.

TIME-SENSITIVE · CLAIM GROUP 3 · REVIEWED AND UPDATED OCTOBER 2026 · HARD NUMBER “on average from 15-18% of the total purchase price” is the only hard percentage in the article. It is David’s 2017 figure, left exactly as he wrote it rather than swapped for a number with no source. Anyone pricing a product today should take the rate from the current fee schedule for their own category.

CON 02The Amazon “A to Z Guarantee” May Actually Work Against You

Amazon has enabled extreme higher conversion, and easy of use to sell your products, however you are truly bound by their rules. That means that just about anything that a customer you send a product to can potentially complain about, will enable them to ask for a refund. An exceptionally entitled audience, and ultimately some sellers see the “Z in the A-to-Z Guarantee” as a big fat Zero for those that have had any issues in regards to those transactions that fall under this policy.

CON 03Amazon has a Standard 14 Day Payment Hold on All Sales

As if Amazon didn’t have billions to play with regarding stocks and their publicly traded shares, but they also hold 90% of all payments for goods in a 2 business week release. So that means if you don’t have your eggs lined up, you are going to be short on cash until they deposit into your bank account. So if you need immediate liquidity, you are going to want to look to selling on Ebay at first to pump up some cash flow, to deal with these issues.

There are some that have gotten the ability for a pushed up payment release, though there is a process involved in this and you can join our powerhouse selling program to get the insights you need to get to that level.

TIME-SENSITIVE · CLAIM GROUP 4 · REVIEWED AND UPDATED OCTOBER 2026 · HARD NUMBERS “14 Day Payment Hold”, “90% of all payments” and “a 2 business week release” are 2017 settlement terms. Payout schedules are a lever marketplaces pull often. The advice built on them — list on the faster-paying platform first if you need liquidity — only holds while the hold periods do.

CON 04Amazon Has Overall Higher Competition for Similar Products

Amazon’s ultimate organization of products pits “seller against seller” on the same exact product. Much of the time some listings have 20+ sellers selling the exact same item. And to make matters worse, the standard seller mentality is to “beat out the price” of the next guy. And this style business practice can lead to profits of like 5%.

“REMEMBER: More Sales Doesn’t Always = More Profit.” DAVID SCARPITTA · 30 MAY 2017
TIME-SENSITIVE · CLAIM GROUP 6 · REVIEWED AND UPDATED OCTOBER 2026 “20+ sellers” and “profits of like 5%” are illustrative of what David was seeing on crowded listings in 2017, not a measured average across the marketplace. The principle in the pull quote above does not age. The two numbers do.

So that’s it entrepreneurs

This is just one way to make money online. So now you know the real Pros and Cons when it comes to Ebay vs Amazon. You can learn more intermediate and advanced techniques on how to win at the 3rd party marketplace game, so please take a moment to signup for more information on getting your business online, no matter what it is.

And the part this article does not say, because in 2017 it did not have to: every pro and con above is a rule set somebody else owns. The fee, the hold, the guarantee, the processor and the competitor sitting on your own listing are all decisions made by a marketplace, and they can all change between the day you read this and the day you ship. The one storefront nobody can rewrite the rules on is your own — which is what our ecommerce online marketing work is for.

Next step

If you sell on either marketplace, the site you actually own is the one we can grade. Run the free card on it.

Test My Site’s SEO
Scorecard — not yet issued

Test My Site’s SEO

AWAITING YOUR URL
Your Site Grade Fill out the info, and we will run the free test for you and get the score.

Your score will be comprised of a multitude of factors from the speed, and proper technical setup to the online respect it currently gets. There is no score shown now, however your report will be created in real time for review.

The six scored lines 0 OF 6 MEASURED
On-page & code structure— / 100
Keyword relevance for your term— / 100
Local & map signals— / 100
Authority & citations— / 100
User experience— / 100
Reputation & reviews— / 100
Every grade and every number on this card comes from your site once you run the test. We don’t publish numbers we haven’t measured — not even as an example.
Where this sits

Counted from our own library, longest first.

  • This guide1,768 w
  • Rank by depth1 of 15
  • Library total10,438 w
  • Oldest guide27 Jan 2012
  • Newest guide28 Apr 2018

Nothing has been published since 28 April 2018. We would rather say that out loud than back-date a page to look busy.

Rather be measured than read?

Find the real problems with your site and brand. One URL, one keyword, and you get the full report and then talk to a real person about it: 1-323-505-6622

Test My Site’s SEO

Or talk to a person: 1-323-505-6622

REVIEW LOGThe honest part

Reviewed and Updated October 2026

Refreshing a 2017 post and leaving a false 2017 claim inside it is worse than leaving the post alone. So the date and the URL stay, David’s text stays as he wrote it, and every time-sensitive claim carries a dated note where it sits.

Revision history — complete
  • Published — 30 May 2017Original article by David Scarpitta, 1,768 words. This is also the last modified date recorded on the live site: the post has never been edited.
  • Rebuild — this templateReading layout, contents, accuracy card and claim notes added. The article text is unchanged, the URL is unchanged, and the publish date has not been touched.
  • Reviewed and Updated — October 2026The six time-sensitive claim groups were reviewed and each got a dated note. The structured data on this page reports 30 October 2026 as the modified date.
How this template handles age, as a rule. The date stays. The URL stays. The body is not re-written to say something it never said. Anything time-sensitive gets a yellow note where it sits, and the accuracy card at the top carries the review date: the date the notes were written, not a re-stamp of the article.
Next step

The rules in this guide belong to two marketplaces. The site you own is the one we can grade, free.

Test My Site’s SEO

WRITTEN BYMarked by

The people who answer are the people who do it.

David Scarpitta

Chief Creative Officer and your partner at Get Found Marketing

David has been publishing plain-English search and selling advice on this domain since January 2012 — 15 guides and 10,438 words of it, of which this is the longest. He writes them as “Get Found Facts”: first person, no jargon, and a straight answer to the question people actually typed.

Thanks for finding us. The next job is getting the world to find you.

RELATEDFrom the library of 15

Read next — with their real ages on them

Five real guides from our own library, with the word count and publish date counted from the live site. The age chip is part of the card on purpose: you should be able to see how old a guide is before you open it.

SEO6 JAN 2015 Is it Worth Doing SEO?

The question every marketplace seller asks once the platform fees start biting: is it worth building search traffic you own instead of renting someone else’s?

896 WORDSRead the guide ›
SEO24 FEB 2015 · DATED Is Wix Good For SEO, Ecommerce or Websites in General?

The other half of the “where do I sell” decision — your own store. Flagged in our content plan as materially out of date: the product it reviews has changed substantially.

855 WORDSRead the guide ›
SEO10 FEB 2015 · DATED Getting My Business On Google & Getting Found in Searches

Getting found off-marketplace. Flagged for rewrite rather than refresh — Google’s business listing product has been renamed and rebuilt since this was written.

993 WORDSRead the guide ›
SEO1 FEB 2016 Guide to Finding The Best SEO Marketing Companies

How to tell a search marketing company that will move your numbers from one that will sell you a template. The second-longest guide in the library.

1,302 WORDSRead the guide ›
ONLINE MARKETING27 APR 2018 Domain Name Investing

The newest long guide on the site, and the companion to “What is Domaining?”. Note that its dollar figures carry the same 2017–2018 caveat as the fee numbers above.

1,147 WORDSRead the guide ›
THE HUB15 GUIDES All 15 guides, grouped and dated

SEO (7), What Does The Term Mean (7), Online Marketing (3) and Selling My Product Online (1) — 10,438 words going back to 27 January 2012, every one with its real date on it.

10,438 WORDSOpen the library ›
This is the only guide in its category

“Ebay vs Amazon Selling” is the single post in Selling My Product Online — one post in a category of its own, and the longest thing on the site. It is the obvious centre of a marketplace-selling cluster, and the four follow-ups it already promises are the cluster’s outline.

Next step

Reading is free. So is the card. Point it at the site you own and see what it says.

Test My Site’s SEO
The last card

Stop Losing On the Net and Start Winning.

You have read nine years of pros and cons about two marketplaces you do not own. Let us grade the one you do. We will treat your store as our own business.

Test My Site’s SEO — free
Or talk to a person 1-323-505-6622

Selling on Amazon or eBay and want the traffic to come to your own store instead? Ask about ecommerce online marketing, where free visitors beat paid ones.

Contact A Consultant